Based on evidence they've seen thus far involving the fatal police shooting of a black motorist in North Charleston, S.C., local police chiefs believe homicide charges filed against the policeman are justified, and said options are available before such deadly force is used.
Officer Michael Thomas Slager, who is white, is accused of shooting eight times at Walter Scott - striking him three times in the back, once in the upper buttocks and once in the ear - when he fled on foot from the officer after being pulled over for a broken brake light April 4. Cellphone video taken by a witness shows the officer shooting Scott.
"It's doesn't look good for the officer," Mount Carmel Township Chief of Police Brian Hollenbush said. "From everything I've seen and read about the shooting, I believe it was justified to charge the officer with murder at this point."
Hollenbush said the most troubling issue he had about the incident was why a routine traffic stop turned into a deadly shooting. "What escalated it to get the officer to use deadly force?" he asked.
Using Tasers, spray
He said most officers have two cartridges in Taser guns they carry as part of their
normal equipment. He said if Tasers don't stop a suspect from becoming aggressive, officers are trained to then use OC spray. If that approach doesn't work, he said police normally will engage in a physical confrontation with the suspect. Only as a last, desperate resort do police normally use deadly force, Hollenbush said.
"I could see the officer firing his gun if the suspect was running away and pulled out a weapon," he said, "but that apparently wasn't the case here."
Shamokin Police Chief Darwin Tobias III agreed with Hollenbush about the procedures officers follow in such circumstances.
"I was shocked when I first saw the video," Tobias said. "Unfortunate circumstances occurred, and whether the shooting was intentional or unintentional, a mistake was made by the officer."
Tobias said Tasers are not a "cure all" when encountering aggressive suspects.
"We've had instances where Tasers malfunction or the prongs don't stop a suspect from continuing their unruly behavior," he said. "We are trained to neutralize a suspect, whether that takes one shot or eight shots, from preventing further harm to anyone or themselves. I believe the officer was wrong in how he approached the situation, although it's still not clear exactly what happened before the shooting. But it doesn't look good at this point."
Mount Carmel Police Chief Todd Owens said he seen few of the media accounts of the shooting due to a busy week of work, and therefore reserved judgment on the officer's actions. But the veteran policeman acknowledged officers are certainly not trained to shoot eight times at an unarmed, fleeing suspect.
"There are always better options than using deadly force when a suspect is fleeing," Owens said.
Coal Township Police Chief William Carpenter and Sunbury Chief of Police Brad Hare reserved comment about the shooting.
Local cases
Hare and Sunbury Sgt. James Taylor know what it's like to be forced to shoot someone to defend themselves.
Fortunately, the suspects they shot did not die and have recovered from their wounds.
On July 8, Hare shot Erick R. Trometter, 23, formerly of Sunbury, in the groin area after the defendant, who earlier in the day assaulted his 67-year-old grandmother, Amanda Trometter, resisted arrest, pulled a large knife on the officer and approached him in a threatening manner.
Hare, who deployed a Taser three times in an unsuccessful attempt to stop Trometter from coming toward him, fired one shot, wounding the defendant. Trometter spent seven weeks recovering in Geisinger Medical Center in Danville.
Trometter, who faces multiple charges in the shooting and assault, was ordered last month by Northumberland County Judge Charles H. Saylor to be evaluated by a psychiatrist before his criminal case proceeds. He remains incarcerated in lieu of $250,000 bail.
Taylor faced a similar situation as Hare when he was forced to shoot Naheem J. Reams as he attempted to run over the officer June 5, 2013, near Chestnut and Front streets, following a high-speed chase in the city.
Reams, 18, of Shamokin, who was 17 at the time of the incidents, was charged by state police Aug. 2, 2013, with multiple offenses, including felonies of aggravated assault and fleeing or attempting to elude police, and driving under the influence of marijuana.
Reams spent 20 days in the hospital before being placed in a juvenile detention facility on an unrelated warrant. After being charged in relation to the chase, he was committed to Northumberland County Prison.
In December, he pleaded guilty to numerous charges, including felonies of aggravated assault and fleeing or eluding police, and was sentenced by Saylor to two to five years in state prison followed by three years consecutive probation.