SUNBURY - The attorney for accused murderer Edgar A. Gearhart will argue in the Court of Common Pleas that his client is not guilty of first or second degree murder because he did not intend to stab to death his mother's boyfriend or show any malice in his actions.
The 19-year-old defendant from Selinsgrove, who appeared very nervous and even scared at times during his 35-minute preliminary hearing Friday morning before Magisterial District Judge Benjamin Apfelbaum, cried upon being escorted from the public meeting room at Northumberland County Administration Center after being held for court on multiple charges, including an open count of criminal homicide and attempted homicide.
The hearing was moved from Apfelbaum's small courtroom, which is located in the same building, to accommodate more people.
Gearhart, who did not testify, pleaded not guilty to all charges at the outset of the legal proceeding.
His attorney, James Best of Sunbury, said there was no case for first or second degree murder against Gearhart because of the lack of intent, premeditation or malice in his actions.
Northumberland County District Attorney Ann Targonski argued that case laws allows an open count of criminal homicide to be filed because the defendant used a deadly weapon on a vital organ of the body and recklessly or negligently caused the March 18 death of 46-year-old Robert "Knowledge" Blake, of 620 N. Fifth St., Sunbury.
An open count of criminal homicide includes first, second and third degree murder, voluntary manslaughter or involuntary manslaughter.
'Tragedy'
Gearhart is charged by Sunbury Cpls. Jamie Quinn and Travis Bremigen with stabbing to death Blake on Masser Street between Fifth and Sixth streets, a short distance from Blake's home. Prior to stabbing Blake, Gearhart also is accused of using a knife to cut the left shoulder of his mother and Blake's girlfriend, Amy Gearhart, 40, of Selinsgrove, while giving her a hug inside a friend's home.
The stabbings were reported to police at about 2 a.m.
Apfelbaum ruled the commonwealth presented sufficient evidence to send the case to the Court of Common Pleas for a pre-trial conference June 5. Gearhart was remanded back to SCI-Coal Township without bail.
After the hearing, Best said, "There is a low standard of proof at preliminary hearings. The defense's case will play out more at the Common Pleas level and I anticipate filing several motions that challenge the reasons why first or second degree murder don't apply against my client."
Targonski added, "This case is a tragedy. The loss of a 46-year-old person's life is always sad. Mr. Blake's death was unnecessary."
Following the hearing, the defendant's mother yelled to her son, "I love you."
Amy Gearhart was among about 10 family members and friends who came to support the young defendant and collectively maintain his innocence.
Although he declined to identify himself, one of Gearhart's friends criticized Sunbury police for "not doing their job right." He said, "If Sunbury police did their job right, this incident wouldn't have made it that far. They should have investigated the incidents that led up to this."
The man did not elaborate what the alleged prior incidents involved before walking away.
While Gearhart's family members and friends were disgruntled about the judge's ruling when talking to Best outside the center, Targonski explained to Blake's three nieces inside the meeting room how the case will most likely proceed. The nieces declined comment about the fatal stabbing of their uncle.
Testifying for the prosecution were Northumberland County Coroner James Kelley, Tara Michael and Quinn.
Kelley said Blake was pronounced dead by a physician in the emergency room at Sunbury Community Hospital.
He said an autopsy at Lehigh Valley Hospital in Allentown determined Blake died from stab wounds to his right thigh, which severed his femoral artery, the main supplier of blood to the lower body. He said the manner off death was homicide.
Testimony
Michael, a friend of the Gearharts who lives at 622 N. Sixth St., said she and Amy Gearhart were drinking alcoholic beverages at her home and just "hanging out" during the evening and early-morning hours prior to the stabbings.
The witness said Edgar Gearhart and Blake both showed up later to arrange a ride for Amy Gearhart back to Selinsgrove.
A few moments after she saw Edgar Gearhart give his mother a hug, Michael recalled Amy Gearhart, stating, "Oh my God, I think I was stabbed."
Michael described the cut on her friend's left shoulder as being deep and several inches long. She said the stab wound produced a lot of blood.
She said the defendant left the home with Blake after the stabbing. She said there was no argument or fighting between the two of them.
Quinn talked about the police investigation that led to the charges filed against the defendant.
She said Blake was found covered in blood on a porch at 616 N. Fifth St. "He was in bad shape. He was alive, but not responding," she said.
The corporal said there were bloody footprints on the sidewalk leading to the porch.
Quinn said Edgar Gearhart, who was found at the scene with Blake, was calling the victim's name and attempted to help him.
Minutes later, she said police were notified about Amy Gearhart being stabbed.
The corporal said the defendant admitted jabbing a knife into Blake's right thigh in an alley during an argument. Quinn said the knife used in Blake's stabbing was found in a nearby vehicle.
But she said Edgar Gearhart claimed he didn't know anything about his mother's stabbing. Quinn testified Edgar Gearhart told her that he and his mother got into an argument earlier about getting a ride home and a broken cellphone.
When contacted by police after the stabbings by police, Amy Gearhart initially refused medical treatment for her stab wound, Quinn testified. But the corporal said Gearhart later agreed to be taken by a friend to Sunbury Community Hospital before being transferred to Geisinger Medical Center, Danville.
Quinn said Gearhart did not want to press charges against her son.